Volume : 2, Issue : 7, JUL 2016


Main Naser Alolayyan, AlaEldin Mohammad Hasan Awawdeh


Total Quality Management (TQM) is being practiced in any organizations worldwide including healthcare services. Therefore, this paper will discuss the literature review on the basis and principles of TQM and its implementations in healthcare-related industry. From the literature, it is suggested that TQM is suitably adopted as it can improve patients‟ satisfaction, reduce cost and reduce medical errors.
This study aims at studying the impacts of TQM implementation on patients‟ satisfaction level in Jordanian university hospitals through considering operational flexibility as mediating variable. The study moreover attempts to highlight the important role of TQM and operational flexibility on patients‟ satisfaction. On other hand, it plans to develop a model on activating the TQM implementations and operational flexibility to improve patient satisfaction.


total quality management, health care, operation flexibility, patient satisfaction.

Article : Download PDF

Cite This Article

Article No : 6

Number of Downloads : 394


1. Ahire S. L.; Golhar D. Y. and Waller M. A. 1996. Development and validation of TQM
implementation constructs. Decision sciences. 27(1): 23-31.
2. Al-Eisa I. S., Al-Mutar M. S., Radwan M. M., AL-Terkit A. M. 2005. Patient satisfaction
with primary health care services at capital health region, Kuwait. Middle East
Journal of family medicine 3: 10-16.
3. Alsharif B. F. T. 2008. Patient's satisfaction with hospital services at Nablus district,
west bank, Palestine. Unpublished master thesis, Al- Najah national university. Palestine.
4. Andaleeb S. S. 1998. Determinants of customer satisfaction with hospital: an managerial
model. International Journal of health care quality assurance 11(6): 181-187.
5. Badri M. A., Attia S. and Ustadi A. M. 2009. Healthcare quality and moderators of
patient satisfaction: testing for causality. International Journal of health care quality
assurance 22(4): 382-410.
6. Baker R. 1991. Audit and standards in new general practice. BMJ 303:32-34.
7. Baker R. and Streatfield J. 1995. What type of general practice do patients prefer?
Exploration of practice characteristics influencing patient satisfaction. British journal
of general practice. 45: 654-659.
8. Boshoff L. and Gray B. 2004. The relationships between service quality, customer satisfaction
and buying intentions in the privet hospitals industry. South African journal of
business management, 35(4): 27-37.
9. Buchbinder S. and Shanks N. 2007. Introduction to health care management. Jones and
Bartlett publishers.
10. Burns D. J. and Neisner L. 2006. Customer satisfaction in a retail setting. International
Journal of retail and distribution Management 34(1): 49-66. Chan F.T.S.
2004. Impact of operation flexibility and dispatching rules on the performance of a flexible
manufacturing system. International journal advance manufacturing technology,
11. Choi K., LEE H., Kim C., Lee S. 2005. The service quality dimensions and patient satisfaction
relationship in South Korea: Comparisons across gender age and types of service.
Journal of services marketing, 19(3): 140-149.
12. Correa H. L. and Gianesi I. G. N. 1994. Service operation flexibility. International conference
of the European operation management association.
13. Ditto P. H., Moore K. A., Hilton J. A., Jonathan K. R. 1995. Beliefs about physicians:
their role in health care utilization, satisfaction, and compliance. Basic and applied
social psychology, 17(1): 23- 48.
14. Duggirala M., Rajendran C. and Anantharaman R. N. 2008a. Patient-perceived dimensions
of total quality service in health care. Benchmarking An International Journal,
15(5): 560-583.
15. Duggirala M., Rajendran C. and Anantharaman R. N. 2008b. Provider-perceived
dimensions of total quality management in health care. Benchmarking An International
Journal, 15 (6): 693-722.
16. Frankline J. S. P. 2001. Patient satisfaction in Alberta: An empirical analysis. Published
master thesis. University of Alberta, Canada.
17. Gaither N. and Frazier G. 2002. Operation management 9ed South Western.
18. Gilbert F. W., Lumpkin J. R., Dant R. P. 1992. Adaptation and customer expectations of
health care options. Journal of health care management, 12 (3): 46-55.
19. Gilbert F. W., Lumpkin J. R., Dant R. P. 1992. Adaptation and customer expectations of
health care options. Journal of health care management, 12 (3): 46-55.
20. Gremigni P., Sommaruga M., Peltenburg M. 2008. Validation of health care communication
questionnaire (HCCQ) to measure outpatients' experience of communication
with hospital staff. Patient education and counseling, 71: 57-64.
21. Grimes F. 2003. Patient satisfaction. Guidelines, the measurement of patient satisfaction.
Health strategy implementation project.
22. Harvey J., Lefebvre L. A. and Lefebvre E. 1997. Flexibility and technology in services:
a conceptual model. International journal of operation and production management,
17(1): 29-45.
23. Hills R. and Kitchen S. 2007. Toward a theory of patient satisfaction with physiotherapy:
Exploring the concept of satisfaction. Physiotherapy theory and practice, 23(5):
24. Idris F., 2006. A survey of service operations in new emerging economies. (On line)
25. Imam S. Z., Syed K. S., Ali S. A., Ali S. U., Fatima K., Gill M., Hassan M. O., Hashmi S.
H., Siddiqi M. T., Khan H. M. and Jameel O. F. 2007. Patients' satisfaction and opinions
of their experiences during admission in a tertiary care hospital in Pakistan. A cross sectional
study. BMC Health Services Research, 7:161.
26. Ishikaw H., Takayama T., Yamazaki Y., Seki Y., Katsumata N. 2002. Physician patient
communication and patient satisfaction on Japanese cancer consultation.Social science
and medicines, 55:301-311.
27. Johnson M. A. 1995. The development of measures of the cost of quality for an engineering
unit. International Journal of quality and reliability management 12(2): 86-
28. Jr J. E. W., Davies-Avery A. and Stewart A. L. 1977. The measurement and meaning of
patient satisfaction: A review of the literature. Health and medical care services review.
29. Kennedy M. T. and Fiss P. C. 2009. Institutionalization, framing and Diffusion: the
logic of TQM adoption and implementation decisions among U.S. hospitals.Academy
of management Journal, 52(5): 897-918.
30. Kovner A. R. and Knickman J. R. 2008. Health care delivery in the United States, 9th
edition, Springer Publishing Company. New York.
31. Kujala J., Lillrank P., Kronstrom V., and Pettokorpia A. 2006. Time based management
of patient process. Journal of health organization and management. 20 (6): 512-524.
32. Lovdal L. and Peerson R. 1989. Wanted doctors who care. Journal of health marketing,
9(1): 37-41.
33. McFadden K. L., Stock G. N. and Gowen III C. R. 2006. Implementation of patient
safety initiatives in U.S. hospitals. International journal of operation and production
management, 26 (3): 326-347.
34. Miguel P. A. 2006. Quality management through a national quality a ward framework.
The TQM magazine, 18(6): 626-637.
35. Mohanty R. P., Santhi K. and Haripriya C. 1996. A model for evaluation TQM effectiveness
in health-care systems. Work study 45(2): 14-17.
36. Naidu A. 2008. Factors affecting patient satisfaction and health care quality.
International Journal of health care quality assurance 22(4): 366-381.
37. Newman K.; Maylor U. and Chansarkar B. 2002. The nurse satisfaction service quality
and nurse retention chain. Journal of management in medicine. 16(4): 271-291.
38. Oluwatoyin A. and Oluseun A. 2008. Total quality management. Master dissertation.
Bleking institute of technology. Nigeria.
39. Pheng L. S. and Teo J. A. 2004. Implementing total quality management in construction
firms. Journal of management in engineering. 20(1): 8-15.
40. Polluste K., Kalda R., and Lember M. 2000. Primary health care system in transition:
the patient's experience. International journal for quality in health care, 12(6):503-
41. Psychogios A. and Priporas C. 2007. Understanding total quality management in context:
qualitative research on managers' awareness of TQM aspects in the Greek service
industry. The qualitative report, Vol. 12(1): 40-66.
42. Sadikoglu E. and Zehir C .2010. Investigating the effects of innovation and employee
performance on the relationship between total quality management practices and firm
performance: An empirical study of Turkish firm. International journal of production
economics. 10.1016/j.ijpe.2010.02.013. pp 1-13
43. Samat N., Ramayah T., Yousoff Y. M. 2008. Do ISO certified SME's have higher quality
practices? Empirical insights from the northern region of Malaysia. International
journal of business and management, 3 (3):66-75.
44. Samson D. and Terziovski M. 1999. The relationship between total quality management
practices and operational performance. Journal of operation management. 17:
45. Sila I. and Ebrahimpour M. 2003. Examination and comparison of the critical factors of
total quality management (TQM) across countries. International journal of production
research. 41(2): 235-268.
46. Sivadas E. and Baker-Prewitt J. L. 2000. An examination of the relationship between
service quality, customer satisfaction and store loyalty. International Journal of retail
and distribution management 28(2): 73-82.
47.Smith A. D and Offdile F. O. 2008. Data collection Automation and Total Quality Management
case studies in the health-service industry. Health marketing quarterly 25 (3):
48. Tucker J. III and Adams S. R. 2001. Incorporating patients' assessments of satisfaction
International Educational Scientific Research Journal [IESRJ] 20
Research Paper E-ISSN No : 2455-295X | Volume : 2 | Issue : 7 | July 2016
and quality: an integrative model of patients' evaluation of their care. Managing service
quality, 11(4): 272-286.
49. Verdu A. J. and Gomez-Gras J. 2009. Measuring the organization responsiveness
through managerial flexibility. Journal of organization change management, 22(6):
50. Vukmir R. B. 2006. Customer satisfaction. International Journal of health care quality
assurance 19(1): 8-31.
51. Walston S. L., AL-Omar B. A., AL-Muteri F. A. 2010. Factors affecting the climate of
hospital patient safety. International journal of health care quality assurance, 23(1):
52. Webb K. 2007. Exploring patient, visitor and staff perspectives on patients' experiences
of care. Journal of management and marketing in health care, 1(1): 61-72.
53. Yi Si te W., Ooi K. B., Lin B., and Chong A. Y. 2009. TQM and customer satisfaction in
Malaysia service sector. Industrial Management and data system 109 (7): 957-975.
54. Zineldine M. 2006. The quality of health care and patient satisfaction. International
Journal of health care quality Assurance 19(1): 60-92.